The European Parliament has greenlit a temporary revival of controversial “chat scanning” rules that let online platforms voluntarily scan private communications for child sexual abuse material (CSAM) — but it carved out a crucial exception for end-to-end encrypted messages, a change that has grabbed attention across the crypto community.
What happened
- On July 9, Parliament voted to revive the temporary framework (sometimes dubbed “Chat Control 1.0”) that expired in April, extending voluntary scanning powers for platforms through 2028.
- A bid to formally reject the Council’s position drew 314 votes in favor of rejection, 276 against and 17 abstentions — short of the absolute majority (361) required to block the measure. Because the rejection motion failed, the temporary framework moves forward.
- Parliament simultaneously approved an amendment excluding communications protected by end-to-end encryption (E2EE). That amendment passed comfortably: 369 in favor, 236 against, 6 abstentions.
What the rules do — and don’t do
- The temporary rules permit online service providers to detect, remove and report suspected CSAM on a voluntary basis. Supporters say the framework gives platforms legal clarity to act against abuse.
- Privacy advocates warned that broad scanning risks sweeping up innocent users’ private communications and increasing surveillance.
- Crucially for security-conscious services, the Parliament’s amendment states the framework “should not cover communications to which end-to-end encryption is, has been or will be applied,” shielding E2EE-protected traffic from mandatory scanning under this temporary law.
Why crypto stakeholders are alarmed
- Wallets, recovery phrases, private keys and other sensitive on-device secrets rely on device-level security and encrypted channels. Blockchain groups and security experts have warned that client-side scanning — tools that inspect content on a user’s device before encryption — could expose seed phrases, session keys and other critical data.
- The International Association for Trusted Blockchain Applications flagged new attack surfaces if scanning tools gain broad access to files on users’ devices, and raised concerns for open-source wallet and dApp developers who might face compliance burdens despite not controlling the underlying networks.
- Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin criticized the move before the vote, warning that lawmakers were attempting to “push Chat Control through again.”
Political fallout and next steps
- Pirate Party MEP Markéta Gregorová called the result “a bittersweet victory,” applauding the E2EE protection while lamenting that voluntary mass scanning passed.
- The amended proposal now returns to the Council of the European Union. The Council can accept Parliament’s changes or reject them and reopen negotiations — meaning the final shape of the extension is still uncertain.
- Separately, a broader permanent regulation often referred to as “Chat Control 2.0” remains under negotiation; talks are expected to resume in September. Key disputes linger, including whether detection should target specific suspected users or be applied broadly across services, and how to reconcile abuse-fighting measures with strong encryption.
Bottom line for crypto users and developers
For now, E2EE-protected communications have explicit protection from the current temporary scanning framework. But voluntary scanning and the threat of client-side inspection remain possible for unencrypted flows, and the debate over permanent rules continues. Crypto projects should watch the Council’s response and upcoming negotiations closely — the technical and security implications could be significant for wallets, key management and decentralized applications.
Read more AI-generated news on: undefined/news
